Showing posts with label Chetan Bhagat. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Chetan Bhagat. Show all posts

Book Review: The Girl In Room No 105 by Chetan Bhagat




                   Well, Chetan Bhagats books are like Salman Khan films. They are obviously immune to any kind of reviews or criticism.No matter what you write or think about their works, they will invariably rake in the moola.

              First things first- The girl in Room No 105 (TGIR) is neither a  parody nor a rip off of Ruth Ware's "The Woman in ..."(which was no masterpiece by any stretch of imagination), infact the only similarity between the two works ends with the title. To be very frank, TGIR is far better than Bhagat's last two outings. Though it has all his usual cliches' in place (the loser IIT alumni hero, the ''liberal, super sexy heroine and their chance meeting at the IIT , to name a few ), this one is more of a crime thriller (pretty half baked one at that) with a few genuinely funny conversations thrown in between.

          Our protagonist is Keshav, the loser IIT guy who is now employed with 'Chandan classes', an IIT JEE tuition centre. His best buddy is Saurabh aka Golu who is also his colleague at ''Chandan'.One night, Keshav gets a call from his ex- girl friend inviting him to visit her at her hostel room. Keshav turns up there only to find her murdered.How Keshav along with his Watson (Saurabh) finds the mystery behind her murder is what the book is all about.

        As I mentioned before, TGIR is far better than any of Bhagat's recent works. Chetan has tried his hand in a new genre and has been able to come up with something half decent.The book undoubdtedly is a time pass read with the typical Chetan Bhagat elements in place. But that doesn't mean that it breaks any new grounds as far as the mystery thriller genre is concerned. If Bhagat's earlier protagonists were used to globe trotting for finding his (their) estranged girl friend(s),here Keshav is doing the same for finding her murderer.The suspense is pretty much predictable and the mystery is the 'kindergarten' variety and obviously there isn't much space for sense and logic in Bhagat's universe!

       Coming to the characters, Golu comes aross as a genuinely funny guy and is the sole source of the occassional one-liners in the story.The other characters are Captain Fyaiz and Raghu (Zara's fiance).The writing and language are typical Chetan Bhagat.

Verdict: I'm going with a 2.75 out of 5.The book is a time-pass read for Chetan Bhagat Fans!


-nikhimenon

'Half- thoughts' on Chetan Bhagat's Half Girl Friend

(This is not a full fledged review of Half-girlfriend.If you want a detailed review of the same,please read it here and here)




                          I was just about 18 when I read Chetan Bhagat's first work as a writer,'Five Point Someone'.Though it was not a great literary piece of work by any stretch of imagination,I loved it for it's genuinely funny/likeable characters and it's inherent honesty.A decade and half a dozen (rather disappointing) books later (not before finishing Bhagat's latest, a couple of hours back),I can only say that it's high time that the 'Sallu bhai of Indian mass market paperback' segment stopped rehashing old Bollywood scripts and passing it off as his 'brand new novel'.

                I have nothing against books written in simple,conversational English with mundane plots as long as they are humorous or atleast manage to entertain me.Half-Girlfriend is not only a rehash of rehashes (of atleast a dozen Indian movies and even CB's own previous works) but is also a largely boring work with plastic and fake characters and situations.There is nothing original or remotely humorous about the book and even the issues addressed topically in the book (the rich-poor divide,corruption among netas,sexual abuse....) have been discussed in a much better and more efficient manner by many others before.As Pulkit rightly says,'HG' reads more like a third rate screenplay with the first Act set in Delhi(the 'half-girl friend' bullshit) and the subsequent ones in Bihar (the speech,the English classes,Bill Gates Foundation grant)  and Newyork(the search for the lost love).Though the Delhi portion was a total let down,I really thought that the things were going to brighten up once the action shifted to Bihar (to be honest,the Bihar sequences were the best thing about about the book).With an uninspiring third act and an unpredictable and cliched climax set in New York,Half Girl Friend ended up as yet another boring saga of puppy love and it's aftermath!

I think these movies and books were Bhagat's references while penning down this tale.

The First Act-Vinnai Thaandi Varuvayaa(Tamil),Bhagat's earlier novels (Two States,Five Point..)
The Second Act- Swades,Vinnai Thaandi Varuvayaa(Tamil- Madhav's depression phase) ,Raja-Rani(Tamil-Telugu/ Jai-Nayantara Cancer Track),
The Third Act-Queen, JabWe Met,First Love (Thai,the climax sequences) 


So,the million dollar question is- Well,is the book a good enough material for a 'Super-hit' Bollywood romantic Comedy? 
                                  To an extend,Yes (considering that a romantic comedy doesn't actually need a brilliant plot for it to succeed and provided someone genuinely talented writes a really humorous and imaginative screenplay for it)

-nikhimenon

Half Girlfriend - Chetan Bhagat

Self - clicked image.

MSM Speaks: With the success of stories in both readership and film viewership, Chetan Bhagat's titles have come a long way. But he was never my first choice in picking up books to read. I must admit, I never respected the fact that he wrote in simple English. I stand corrected, because writing simply is one of the toughest things that a writer has to do, if he wants to connect to his readers (especially if the readers are the masses, who would rarely pick a book). With due respect to Mr. Bhagat and his writing prowess, I believe Half Girlfriend is written keeping in mind that it will be adopted as a movie. Anywayyyyyy, so I received this book as a gift and I decided to give it a go right away. The story is of Madhav Jha (A Bihari, so am I, but I will get to that later), who is an ace basketball player, and accordingly, is six feet tall and handsome prince of Dumraon, which is a sleepy hamlet in Bihar. He gets through St. Stephens College, New Delhi, even though, as Madhav says, his english at that time was bound to give us headaches. Nonetheless, stereotyping aside (since Mr. Bhagat has rightly addressed all the stereotypes of Bihar and Bihari people - and I mean it in a real, non offensive manner) he unexpectedly makes through the college entrance interview on the basis of his star basketball playing skills. Not to forget, the cheeky answers he gives to the panelists (Score one for Madhav!!)

Fraught with fear and the anxiety to fit in, Madhav Jha gets the biggest and unexpected twist of fate at Stephens, he falls in love, with Riya Somani, who is portrayed as the beautiful, rich and sophisticated Delhi girl, who co - incidentally is also a basket ball player. The plot becomes drab with Madhav trying to get her attention, but afraid to open up, while Riya eventually gives him attention - much like the basket ball that passes from hand to hand and you get BASKET!! But Riya is complicated. Very much so. I could not figure out her exact character, nor to be honest, I understood Madhav well. She toys with Madhav, who apparently is constantly horny. 

The story becomes insightful at places where Madhav reminisces about his mother, the Rani Sahiba, the gap between the rich class and the low class, the impossibility of striving in this nation without good English. Good pointers, Mr. Bhagat. However, Riya Somani, after spending ALL of her time with Madhav, decides that she cannot be Madhav's girlfriend (friend-zones him) and offers a compromise - to be his Half Girlfriend: Meaning I-will-hang-out-with-you-but-we-will-not-do-any-of-those-things. It gets whacky when Riya Somani suddenly disappears and Madhav makes his way back to his village - to turn the fate of his mother's school. At this point the story becomes very engaging, though I must tell you that we Biharis don't eat Litti Chokha all the time! What comes in for Madhav next is an opportunity to meet Bill Gates, learn English (courtesy Riya Somani) and find his life upside down, when he thinks that finally things were on track. The chase for love begins and the character of Madhav grows but I feel, certain things were rushed which could have made great impression if they were given a time to develop. 

For me  Half Girlfriend was more like Forrest Gump meets Queen meets Jab We Met plus a flurry of movies that came to my mind while reading.  BUT! You can finish the book quick and it will leave you with light heart (and head) and an impression, that even Chetan Bhagat has matured somewhat as a writer that the masses love. 

My Rating: 2.5/5



Half Girl Friend by Chetan Bhagat


Half girlfriend by Chetan Bhagat is the story of Madhav Jha. He is the fateful prince from Dumraon, Bihar and is passionate about Basketball. He makes his way into the most prestigious English graduation course of the country, when he gets selected into St. Stephens College in Delhi University by using his eligibility from the sports quota. There he meets Riya, an uptown high class girl from Delhi, who comes from a family of means. They have drastic difference if you see the section of the society they come from, the basic thought process that they carry, the value system that they possess and the way in which they take decisions. However they click with each other for a lot of reasons, and ultimately the boy-girl saga that these protagonists engages into, forms almost eighty five percent of what this two sixty page book has to offer.

With the MRP of 176 (highest priced book by Chetan Bhagat), a break of almost four years from fiction novel writing (longest ever taken by the bestselling author), and much buzz about the exclusive distribution of this book using the e-commerce partnership of Flipkart, the book was sold in huge numbers right from the day of its release.

Apart from the story of Madhav and Riya, this book boldly makes an effort to touch upon larger themes like contrast of urban and rural mindset, class conflict, shallowness of the rich lifestyle, and most importantly the lingual slavery that our Hindi and regional language speaking masses have to be under English language. There are commentaries on a range of other social topics too, like always and author has made sincere efforts to be inclusive in touching upon various themes of contextual relevance to the youth of this country. Yes, there is sincerity in the choice of themes that are forming the background of the love story, but because of poor choices in execution, the book touches everything too dramatically and very much on the surface.

While quality of the Literature is something that is always criticized upon for Chetan’s books I nevertheless always refrain from talking about it because I understand the fact that Author has consciously always tried too hard to be the writer for the most ordinary Hinglish generation. This is a fact already much known to everyone, and perhaps also to Chetan who self mocks his works in a portion of the story where Riya when teaching Madhav, most basic English, asks her to read books of “that author who writes simplistic English”. I believe that the treatment of the story telling, even if it is trying to be common, should not be clichéd, repetitive, mundane because of the reason that it is trying to be “non literary”.

There are already movie rights, casting rumors for the same getting viral on the internet for this book, and it is not surprising but equally disappointing that Chetan has again over burdened his characters by cheesy dialogues, pushed over scenes, third grade movie screenplay around them.  Riya somani, who is mysterious, unapologetic for long, self enclosed in her complications could have been a much more vivid character if she was not trapped into the most repetitive descriptions that ever leading lady of Chetan’s books have to go through – the baby pink suits, the perfect eye brows, shiny lips, idiotic girl-boy replies in middle of complicated life traumas.  Madhav Jha is sincere, has a setting around him that he displays in splashes within the story, especially in the under confident moments, where he battles out fear of failures to emerge on top of situations, especially when he conquers the English Speech in front of Bill Gates. However he too is a Chetan Bhagat front man – and is forced upon to crack jokes at silliest of places, appear cute when he should have been better left alone to behave more realistically, use catchy heroic phrases when talking to himself, beat his own trumpet, describe girls in the most stereotypical ways – repeating a lot of what has already been said and heard by the readers, from the mouth of male protagonists of Chetan’s books.

The book is filmy to an extent that you can literally visualize a Swades, a wake up Sid, a Hum Tum and what not from popular Bollywood similar settings in between as its sub plots unfold.  There are online social networks, filled with popular praises yet for the book, because I think different target group and their own personal exposure would perhaps generate a much different response from them. There is a copy of this book around me, in every one’s hand and a lot of people who have started reading it are finding it entertaining so I guess the mass appeal that this phenomenally bankable author promises to deliver has been achieved again, but I feel he needs to regain the sincerity he once possessed in his story telling, and characterization of the simple people his books talk of. The book is predictable, repetitive and I am sure the next book that he would write, would bring better out of him. He is a writer who speaks for the generation he represents, and I certainly hope he does a better job out of it and remembers the roots of his own ideologies and not focus on numbers, and collections.

I rate it a generous 2 on 5.


Five Point Someone, by Chetan Bhagat


About the author:
Chetan Bhagat is one of India’s most known authors. He’s the author of five novels and a collection of essays. All five novels have either already been, or expected to be, made into movies.

Cover and blurb:
The cover is somewhat like a college notebook, and the book is subtitled what not to do at IIT. The cover talks of a college story, of three friends and the darker side of IIT.

My thoughts on the book:
Chetan Bhagat is one of those authors I’ve loved and hated. I guess not every book can be a super hit, but I’ve read four of his five novels, felt two was average, and two was way below par. I’ve this habit of not reading books in order. So when one of my friends saw that I’ve not read CB’s debut book, Five Point Someone, she gave me her copy and told me I have to read that. I decided to complete the set of CB novels and took it eagerly. I’d heard rave reviews of the book from most of my friends, and with the movie 3 Idiots being adapted from this one (loosely adapted, I might add), I thought it possibly couldn’t be worse than the two novels I’ve felt way below par.

Five Point Someone brings to us, the story of three friends and their life in IIT. These three friends are linked, not by common points, but how they don’t have much in common at all. It tells us of their studies, their friendship, their obstacles (including the teachers), the ragging and the revolt and many other aspects of college life that many of us might be able to relate to.

Is the book memorable? No. Not very. It’s a simply written simple story with not a lot of twists and turns etc. It’s a fast paced book which you might pick up on a journey and the plot keeps you occupied for a few hours, save you from boredom on that. There are various characters that you can step into the shoes of and possibly understand their life. You feel intrigued by the depth of friendship between the main trio, and you do wish for a happy ending to the novel, which does happen. This book however is not for those who are really in love with English (like me), and you wish it was narrated better. Looking at the plot more critically, the actions of the characters may not make sense at all, and you start banging your head as to why you took it up in the first place. (It’s something that has happened to me when I’ve read his other novels).

Want a book that’s a definite one-time read and has only enough to keep the imagination occupied for a few hours? Then perhaps this is a book you can try. Not one of my favorites, but not CB’s worst either.



My rating: 2.5/5

Book Details:
Title: Five Point Someone
Author: Chetan Bhagat
ISBN: 9788129104595
Genre: Contemporary
Publishers: Rupa and Company
Price: INR. 95



Reviewed by Leo

Shared with

  1. Indian Quills Review Challenge at The Tales Pensieve


One Night @ A Call Center - Chetan Bhagat

Gist: Chetan Bhagat’s second novel, One Night @ the Call Center, is based on a group of people working at a call center who have a chance encounter with God. The book describes a bunch of completely different characters with differing aims and ambitions, and how they pull themselves together and resolve these issues finally.

Thoughts: When a book is interesting in its story idea, and written in simple language that appeals to the common public, the book is bound to be a good one. But not all the time. What Chetan Bhagat, who I applaud for giving the country a push to read more stories,  does with this book, One Night at a Call Center, is the same. The story, one where the guy tries to woo the girl back, where both of them are working at the same call center, and where another guy is all ready to swoop in and get the girl, it works in a way because it's a storyline we're so used to seeing in movies. The hero, the heroine and the villain. And their characters are quite interesting, even if simple. What makes it go from interesting to hilarious and way unrealistic is the quite exaggerated scenes toward the end. Is the book a bad read? I'd say it can be a one-time read for a short journey, but not something that I'd keep on my bookshelf. 

Rating: 2 stars

WHAT YOUNG INDIA WANTS - Chetan Bhagat



AUTHOR - Chetan Bhagat is the author of five novels, all of which have gone on to become bestsellers. In addition, Chetan is a motivational speaker and columnist. He was named one of the 100 Most Influential People in the World by Time magazine and one of the world’s 100 Most Creative People in Business by Fast Company, USA.

SYNOPSIS - The book is based on Chetan Bhagat’s newspaper columns, and influences drawn from his career as a speaker. He by the medium of it tries to incite discussions and viewpoints on various issues that concern the current political and social center-stage in the country. He also tries to propose solutions to some of them, while summarizing them from his own view point. He narrates the various essays and articles in the book, by speaking on behalf of his readership class which has a majority percentage of youth in it.

PULKIT SPEAKS –
the first non-fiction book from the bestselling author, has a catchy cover and a title worthy enough to be a case study for search engine optimization stuff on the Internet. It is subdivided into three parts, dealing with society, politics and youth, respectively, one at a time. It features two short stories to lighten up the summarized conclusion. My favorite portion of the book though, remains the very first chapter of it. “My journey”, an open letter – displays the varied emotions and introspections of the author, as  he talks about his life, his dreams, his achievements, his failures and his fears. By the simplistic narrative that he uses to share his journey so far, and talking about the frustrations that most of the readers can immediately relate to, he creates an environment of the kind – where anyone ageing between 13-27 would feel the pull to continue reading the rest of the book.

The social commentary covered in the section “Our society” focuses on the common ways with which things happen in our country and the pattern we follow to react to them. It ambitiously compares that pattern to reaction/thinking mechanism of people staying in other parts of the world and tries to impact a psychological change of thought process of the readers. It has an easy expression and tries to bring down every social taboo to black and white picture of the kind, where right things and wrong things appear obvious and clear.  Author intends to form layers in the mind of young readers where they develop a moral consciousness and open-minded approach towards things. He expresses most of his frustration here and suggests optimistic change of policies-which would work to make things better, according to him. Irrespective of how you view them, shallow or deep, some of talks here make sense.

The next section titled “Our Politics” – is rather a leap of reach from the author. He here tries to talk about policy making/proposes changes in the functionality and addresses everything – from foreign policy, reservation politics to economic framework, from defense strategy to trust-deficient of the constitutional bodies. The book would make sense in this part to someone, who is completely out of touch from the English newspaper and news channels. Irrespective of how virtuous some of his recommendations are, you can’t help but point out the shallowness that many of them carry. It is obvious that if you try to widen the scope of your talks to such complex and stretched apart topics of national interest, all in the periphery of mere 35 small hand book pages, at some point of time – you are bound to appear “talking on the surface”. I feel that here he doesn’t even delve enough into any particular issue, before proposing an over simplistic solution to the same and moving onto the next one.
Essays here sometimes talk high school level approach. Somebody who is not well read or not even minutely interested in political science dynamics might him them amusing and “hard hitting” but for others, it has little to offer.

In the third section “Our Youth”, Chetan plays on his forte.
He talks of education system, aspirations that every young student has, dreams of the common youth class, their anger towards things and how they, if given the right grooming, can be instrumental to the big change that we need in society and politics. It features, his famous internet-circulated speech titled “sparks”, which is nothing less than awesome. He in other chapters talks of critical need of Basic English for everyone who wants decent employment, gap between higher education and working-class-grooming, outdated curriculum of school level education and wrong approach of reward that we follow in our grading mechanism. Everywhere he suggests good points on the table. Talks genuinely about all the things that majority of youth of this country wants to say. He impresses them and simultaneously represents them. “Letter to Bapu from generation next on his birthday” and “open letter to Sonia Gandhi from young India” has cynicism, honesty and heart at the right places. Save us from ‘lerds’ is perhaps a rebound from him to those who talk about issues, complicatedly but never proposes solutions – he has taken a pinch at think tanks of the society, the one you see often on television talk shows on prime time. I feel he has a point even in that - A good one. “Can engineers be touchy feely” is the last chapter of this section. It is nothing of substance and may me is merely put to lighten up the mood of the whole thing.

The “Two stories”
“Of Ducks and crocodiles” has a metaphorical critical approach and appears apt to the current political scene.
“The cut off” is a beautiful short story about a boy who tops his school but could not land up to a decent college of his choice. It is a must must read for all parents and children - Realistic, funny and with the right lesson.

RATING – (3 + 0.5)/5.    

It is very easy for someone who sells at the rate that Chetan does to continue doing what he does the best – write a coffee table rom-com, yet he sincerely tries to fulfill the responsibility he has as a youth icon and utilizes his reach by spreading the right message across with the medium of “what young India wants”. He might be lacking in grammar skills, his style of writing might be shallow and lucid, but what is important is that this book has its heart at the right place. I am sure he ended the book with immense satisfaction personally. He is merely trying to generate ideas, incite a view point towards certain things, an approach which is correct morally. I would suggest everyone between the age of 13-23 to give it a try. For others, a much real portrayal of issues in India is put up in Mark Tully’s India in slow motion.

PRICE - Rs 140/- Kanpur Railway station. On printed price

Revolution 2020 - Chetan Bhagat


REVOLUTION 2020

ISBN - 978-81-291-1880-6
FIRST PRINTED - 2011
PAGES - 296
BINDING - Paperback
GENRE - Fiction

AUTHOR - Chetan Bhagat

BEST-SELLERS - Five Point Someone, 2 States

SYNOPSIS - Once upon a time, in small-town India, there lived two intelligent boys.

One wanted to use his intelligence to make money.

One wanted to use his intelligence to start a revolution.

The problem was, they both loved the same girl.

Welcome to Revolution 2020. A story about childhood friends Gopal, Raghav and Aarti who struggle to find success, love and happiness in Varanasi. However, it is not easy to attain these in an unfair society that rewards the corrupt. As Gopal gives in to the system, and Raghav fights it, who will win?

EXCERPT - Aarti and I had a deeper relationship. We saw Raghav as a friend, but not a close one.

'You will make a great air hostess', Raghav said, his tome flirtatious.

'yeah. Whatever,' Aarti said. 'Like dad is going to let me leave Varanasi. There are no airlines here. Only temples. Maybe i can be a temple hostess. Sir, please take a seat on the floor. Prayers will begin soon. Prasad will be served in your seats.'

Raghav laughed again, holding his muscular abdomen. I hate people who are naturally gifted with a flat stomach. Why couldn't god make six-packs a default standard in all males? Did we have to store fat in the silliest places?

FL Speak - And with this, Chetan Bhagat is back! Revolution 2020 was supposed to be carry-on-the-good-work writing after 2 States, which i have to admit was good. But his latest novel turned out to be a dud. A very big dissapointment.

Revolution 2020 has three main characters. Gopal, Raghav and Aarti. The author seems to have a fixation with threesomes, with 3 of his novels having 3 main characters. Anyway, its Gopal and Aarti who steals the plot away with Raghav reduced to being a spectator most of the time. The protagonist, Gopal is the anti-hero whom you will love to hate and love to love.

Varanasi. Home of our three young characters. Gopal and Raghav are friends from childhood and they meet Aarti in school when they were still kids. As time pass, Gopal and Aarti becomes the best of friends and Raghav a good friend of them both. As they reach their teens, Gopal's hormones start to act and he falls in love with Aarti. Aarti acknowlodges that she likes him too but "not like that" [*sigh* this is what happens in bollywood movies!].

Well, i guess you all can figure it out what happens after that? Hint - think Bollywood style. Yes, Aarti falls for the rich and the more hunky Raghav while Gopal, being poor and reduced to just-a-friend slowly loses his friendship. Raghav gets into IIT and Gopal goes to Kota for a year to prepare for his AIEEE once more. Now for the predictible twist. Raghav turns down a job offer at Infosys and chases his dream of being a journalist and start a Revolution to stop the rampant corruption. Gopal, fails to crack AIEEE once more, comes back home dejected. Soon, his father dies and he sells their farming land to a corrupt politician to build a college. You can't help pitying Gopal as he believes whatever he is doing, its not evil.

Aarti is being the confused bimbo. Seeing Raghav busy with his job, she secretly meets with Gopal for coffee at times to rekindle their friendship and not before long they end up sleeping with each other. Kudos Chetan Bhagat. We weren't expecting that! *smirks* Anyway, blah blah blah and as in most Bollywood potboilers, the hero grows a conscience. He sacrifices his love to bring back Raghav and Aarti together and bam! End of Story!

Seriously, i expected a lot more from Bhagat. This is a story that even my hormone-driven teenage brother can come up with in his dreams. Chetan Bhagat, whom i immensely like, is sadly living on the success of his first book. Disappointed.

My Rating - 2 stars

PRICE - INR 140/- [Rupa Publications]

Review: Iliana Xander's 'Love Mom'

  Iliana Xander is making waves globally in the crime fiction genre, and much like Freida Mcfadden and Coolen Hoover (though she is more int...